After Residency Tussle, Wainscott School District Pulls a 180

Two students will be staying in Wainscott School District after a ruling at a Tuesday hearing.

Elisha Osborn and Marianne Ward were telling them that their children "are not residents of the Wainscott School District and are, therefore, not entitled to attend the public schools of this District.”

On Tuesday, the district decided at a hearing the day before the coming school year that the students are, again, residents of the district.

"They decided to accept the kids in Wainscott School District," said Osborn on Tuesday. "There's actually quite a bit more to it than that. But the end result is that they took as proof of evidence that they are residents of Wainscott."

Osborn lives in Wainscott, and Ward in Sag Harbor. The couple has not determined a custodial parent, so when the couple found out last school year that their two children were not considered residents of Wainscott - and they could be charged with fraud should their kids continue attending classes in the district - it came as a shock, and according to Osborn, more of a misunderstanding.

In December, a letter went home in the kids’ school folders asking all parents to provide proof of residency. However, Ward and Osborn said that they never got that form. He said he later gave a document for a rental house in a rush, instead of the home he lives in — both of which are in Wainscott.

“They said, 'You handed in this tax bill that said that you lived on Osborn Farm Lane. You committed fraud.' And I said, I didn’t mean to commit fraud, I just did the easiest thing to do at the time. My arrogance was that everybody knew me.”

Osborn is a graduate of the Wainscott School and the Osborn family has lived in Wainscott for 12 generations. His mother, Iris, was a school board member last year, though

According to Tom Horn, an attorney hired to represent Osborn and Ward, a note came this weekend informing the couple of Tuesday's meeting. The parents had registered their children for school in Wainscott School District despite last year's ruling, and Horn said that should the district rule again this year that that their children were not Wainscott School District residents, an appeal to the State Department of Education would have been a more viable option than appealing last year. Because the students were allowed to finish the school year last spring, he said, an appeal likely could have been denied.

Tuesday's hearing lasted between 60 and 90 minutes, and Horn said that Superintendent Stuart Rachlin - legally acting as a designee for the school board - determined that the students were residents of the district.

Rachlin, who signed the letter last year stating that the students were not residents of the Wainscott School District, declined to comment for this story.

School board member David Egean — who was serving on the school board along with Nancy McCaffrey (his mother-in-law) last year when Iris Osborn resigned — forwarded a request for comment to Rachlin.

"I sensed there was some hard feelings," said Horn about Tuesday's meeting. "I'm not saying either side was creating them. It just seemed to be creating a split in the community. Maybe this will put an end to that."

Barbara F September 05, 2012 at 12:09 PM
All this time and energy spent on a non-issue. Twelve generations and they're quibbling over the type of form sent in? Don't they have anything better to do than this?
sandi kruel September 05, 2012 at 12:32 PM
It was personal...they are trash to do this to children is a SIN!!! There was a reason why Oyster Pond bought out his contract..and to the BOE shame on you, you are put in that position to protect children not allow bullying!! DISGRACE!! Good for the Kids!
Marianne Ward September 06, 2012 at 10:07 PM
Extremely happy that our children were able to begin school, but still trying to process the fact that we even had to go through all of this.  The hearing that took place Tuesday, the day before school started was absolutely horrendous and the fact that it even came to this point is disgusting to me.  (actually I wouldn't call it a hearing it was a "trial" as we were raked over the coals like we were criminals) The law is and always has been on our side.  This residency issue has been going on for months and has been extremely stressful for myself, Elisha and our children.  I had thought school board members and our school superintendents were there to help advocate for it's students.     I find it shameful what Mr Rachlin  has put us and our children thru and I find the Wainscott Board of Education just as shameful for not putting a stop to this bullying and harassment over these many months.  I also find the parent that began all of this shameful as well.  Going to the superintendent alleging our children are not Wainscott residents, with out any knowledge as to our family situation .  Perhaps coming to me first... as a mother, a human being escaped her.  I blame her also for the anguish and anxiety our children have endured through out all of this.  The Wainscott School community of parents and administrators that I once loved and felt privileged to have our children be a part of is no more. And that too is a shame. 
sandi kruel September 07, 2012 at 01:48 AM
Hopefully that parent doesn't ever have to tell their children that they might not get to go to school on the first day because another human being made a "assumption " , what is this world coming to... Heres a thought for these parents ,When you kiss your children goodnight think about the hell you put those kids and parents thru..Shame on all of you.. The Superintendent, the Family and the BOE look in the mirror and see how u like yourselves now.
Steve September 09, 2012 at 04:17 PM
Maybe "Osborn Farm Lane" should have been a clue? By Geez, bub! Foolish waste of time, money and unnecessary pain to the Osborns and their children.


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »