Grand Jury Indicts Edward Orr; Tacks on Added Felony

Man accused of leaving the scene of the accident that killed an Amagansett man in October, faces more charges.

A grand jury handed down an indictment Wednesday against the driver suspected in the hit-and-run accident in Amagansett that killed a 61-year-old pedestrian in October.

Edward L. Orr, a 30-year-old from Montauk, faces a three count indictment, including the felony charge of leaving the scene of an accident, brought against him after his arrest last week, as well as additional charges of tampering with physical evidence, a felony, and a misdemeanor charge of fourth-degree criminal mischief, according to online court records.

Orr reportedly confessed. According to one of the complaints filed against him, he told investigating detectives after being arrested on Feb. 7, “I did it. I hit him.”

While Suffolk County District Attorney Thomas J. Spota's spokesman Robert Clifford confirmed the indictment, the office does not release information on the charges until the indictment is unsealed in court, which is scheduled before Suffolk County Criminal Court Judge William Condon in Riverhead on Friday.

As of Wednesday evening, Orr was still in the custody of the Suffolk County Sheriff's deputies at the jail, where he is being held on $250,000 cash or $500,000 bond.

Following a three-month investigation, East Hampton Town police detectives identified the vehicle that struck John Judge as he crossed Main Street in Amagansett on the evening of Oct. 23, and arrested Orr last week.

With no witnesses to the crash, police were left with only the color paint of the vehicle that eventually tracked to a 2004 Jeep Cherokee. Police claim Orr was driving on the night of the accident, and left Judge bleeding in the street, where he was found by a passerby.

  • RELATED: Victim's Family to Cops: You Brought Us Closure

Even with a confession, prosecutors were hard pressed to file more serious charges than the top charge of leaving the scene of an accident, in which a fatality occurred, a class D felony that is punishable by up to 7 years in prison.

Just in recent weeks, Spota has joined state legislators from the East End who have called for stiffer penalties for hit-and-run drivers. Proposed legislation would ensure greater punishment for drivers who leave an accident.

Proposed legislation would upgrade the crime of leaving the scene of an incident resulting in a death from a class D felony to a class C felony, which has a maximum prison time of 15 years. Other types of hit-and-run offenses would also be upgraded.

According to Sen. Lee Zeldin, R-Shirley, a co-sponsor of the bill with Sen. Kenneth P. LaValle, R-Port Jefferson, the bill was created in the wake of the death of Erika Hughes, a 24-year-old from Mastic, who was killed in a 2011 hit-and-run. The driver, Preston Mimms, 48, was eventually caught and pleaded guilty in December, but his sentence of one-and-a-third to four years in prison outraged her family.

At a press conference last month following the arrest of a driver who allegedly fled after striking and killing a man in Riverhead in late December, Spota said such drivers prevent the victim from getting medical care immediately, and also make it nearly impossible to determine if the driver was intoxicated or impaired by drugs at the time of the crash, which could elevate charges.

Under current law drivers under the influence of drugs or alcohol often receive less of a punishment if they flee the scene of an accident, according to Zeldin's office.

There are certain circumstances in which criminal negligence can be proven in a hit-and-run case, but are often based on statements defendants make to the police.

In one of the South Fork's most notorious hit-and-run accidents, Leslie Jennemann was convicted of elevated charges in the hit-and-run death of a 38-year-old migrant worker was killed in Sagaponack in 2002. She was sentenced to 2 to 6 years following a guilty verdict on second-degree manslaughter and leaving the scene without reporting.

A grand jury indicted her in March 2003, handing up a 17-count indictment, including manslaughter, leaving the scene, evidence tampering, insurance fraud, reckless endangerment, and speeding, according to an article at the time in The New York Daily News. Police initially charged her with leaving the scene and evidence tampering.

Ralebird February 15, 2013 at 06:36 AM
It seems you don't understand the whole concept of bail. Bail cannot be punitive, but can only be set to assure the accused will be present for trial. That's the law.
MARTIN DREW February 15, 2013 at 05:51 PM
Dog - really? This man will do his time ; he is shamed by his actions and will do many years in prison ...remember this ..TRUTH sets you free ..he should of stopped and dealt with the horrible happening ...maybe he left because he was drunk? maybe scared? made a BAD decision ..he will do extra time for his bad judgement . Guaranteed but your public hanging; c'mon we know your trying to be funny? or have you the rope and the desire to lead the posse? what might have been five years in jail will probably be 10-15 ...you pay upfront or when you cheat you pay more ...the terrible thing is he left the guy to die ..maybe he stopped and those lost minutes save his life? that guilt I wish on no-one ; The family has closure now , must you continue to promote your hanging....in public ?
Blanca Femina February 16, 2013 at 09:39 AM
10-15 years IS ALL?! I think he should get life. Sorry, but you TOOK SOMEONE ELSE'S LIFE and didn't say a word about it. This Eddie Orr is SCUM OF THE EARTH as far as I'm concerned.
matt stutterheim February 17, 2013 at 06:43 PM
In all likelihood it was an accident, not intentional from all accounts. What was intentional was leaving the scene and trying to cover up the evidence. I would be curious about why the victim was crossing the road with traffic coming. But also, why Mr. Orr didn't see him. As to running away, well that is understandable for someone in a panicked state. Everything after that is just a snowballing of errors in judgment. A sad case all around for all concerned.
Blanca Femina February 18, 2013 at 06:29 AM
Wait, Matt, I'm sorry... are we REALLY making excuses for this guy right now?! He hit somebody, didn't stop, then tried to cover it up, and never admitted to it - that's right, at NO TIME did his conscience tell him to turn himself in for the sake of that family - until after he was caught. As for why somebody dared to cross the road, it kind of doesn't matter - who says traffic was heavy? Maybe the car came out of nowhere? Or maybe it didn't which doesn't matter - pedestrians have the right of way. Maybe Orr did / maybe Orr didn't go out of his way to hit this guy, but he sure as hell went out of his way to pretend it never happened, no matter how much the family was going through.
MARTIN DREW February 18, 2013 at 02:39 PM
Blanca - when caught - he confessed .. If he stopped .. Might have never been charged with a crime IF he wasn't drunk ... Leaving indicates .. MAYBE he was drunk .. staying and drunk - 5 years .. In prison .. Leaving and drunk ... 15 years ... Probably .. He is now on that path . Don't worry he will do time .. Now it's time to congratulate the EHPD for a job well done . Det .Chris Anderson & his team deserve thanks / the family has closure - a criminal caught ; and now attention brought to a known problem .. (dangerous crossing area ) .. In the victims memory; find time to lobby officials to fix the area .. Dark Sky folks wake up to public safety .. And should be quiet on public use over private desire to keep our streets safe . Again hats off to good police work .
Blanca Femina February 19, 2013 at 05:34 AM
yes, good job EHPD. back to the topic at hand: shouldn't BEING A COMPLETE PIECE OF CRAP get you another 35+ years?


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something