Officials: No Public Health Threat at Georgica Pond After Dog's Death

A dog died of liver after failure reportedly ingesting water from Georgica Pond that may have been tainted from blue-green algae.

State and local officials have enlisted the help of scientists to investigate a report that a dog died from blue-green algae exposure after it ingested water from Georgica Pond in East Hampton Village.

Now the East Hampton Town Trustees, together with state, county and town Natural Resources director Kim Shaw, are coming together to develop a program for water testing at several bodies of water throughout town.

The small dog was roaming around the shoreline with another dog, unmonitored, on Sept. 8 when it reportedly drank the water and became ill, according to Christopher Gobler, a marine science professor at Stony Brook University, who said he received the information from state officials to test the water on Sept. 21.

The owner reportedly took the sick dog to an emergency veterinary clinic for medical care. It died a few days later, reportedly of liver failure due to a bacteria found called cyanobacteria, also known as blue-green algae, which produces a toxin harmful to the liver.

His test, performed Sept. 21, found only low levels of blue-green algae were present.

The trustees learned of the situation just before its last meeting, according to Diane McNally, the trustee secretary.

Both McNally and Gobler said there is no known public health threat.

"It's very unfortunate," McNally said. "The implications that we now have a dangerous pond, it's a little premature."

She said the dog was at large, with at least one other dog who did become ill, and there are no witnesses that the canine actually drank from the pond. "You can't pinpoint Georgica Pond water," she said. The algae "could also show up in a mud puddle, a bird bath, a bucket of water. There's no way to know for sure."

Gobler agreed, adding that it could be an anomalous event. However, there's been a negative trend in terms of water quality on the East End.

RELATED: Check out Recent Bay Keeper Report

Gobler said this is not an uncommon occurrence elsewhere. "Scientists don't understand why," he said, but animals seem to be attracted to this type of algae.

Blue-green algae floats at the surface during warmer water temperatures and is more prevalent in bodies of water that don't flush out well. It can be caused by higher levels of nitrates, which can come from septic tanks, fertilizers and road run off, he said. "If the wind is blowing in a particular direction it can concentrate in one place — that can be a problem," he said.

However, he wanted to make it clear that there's no need to panic. Particularly with temperatures decreasing, Gobler said there should be no concern about using Georgica Pond — though he wouldn't recommend allowing dogs to drink from it. "Unless people are drinking the water, it's not a human health threat," he said.

McNally said she has never heard before of an animal dying from ingesting water in East Hampton.

Gobler, who has studied Lake Agawam in Southampton extensively for 10 years, said he has not studied Georgica Pond. McNally said there hasn't been any cause to study that body of water.

"We need more information," McNally said. "The more data we have the better."

The trustees have not discussed a figure yet for how much testing will cost. Gobler will likely be hired to do so, she said.

tito October 10, 2012 at 05:53 PM
maybe now the georgica association will allow for beach access for the trustees to open the pond up and refresh the waters.
R Truth October 10, 2012 at 05:53 PM
regardless if that water is toxic or not, no one will ever know the truth.. the town & government would NEVER let that info out as it would hurt the land value and we all know who lives around that pond.
Bill Graham October 10, 2012 at 09:08 PM
does anyone know when they plan to open the cut?
tito October 11, 2012 at 01:02 AM
the georgica association is not allowing the traditional overland beach access privileges for the use of machinery to open the cut to the eh town trustees. so answer might be, not soon, or when basements along the pond start flooding.
SadderBudweiser October 11, 2012 at 01:59 AM
Get the shovel Jeeves.
eh October 11, 2012 at 12:09 PM
Maybe next time sand is removed from the Pond area it is used to replenish areas that are East Of the Pond - as the machines can no longer transit the beach to West, I'm sure those homeowners who have gotten that sand in prior years will thank their neighbors - it pays to be nice
Dorine Drohan October 11, 2012 at 02:33 PM
My Dog drank the Ptown water in Cape Cod and was sick from it. Green came out of him. A lady said he was going to die in 3 years because the water is polluted and the animals are dying from it. My dog died two years later. A year ago. He was a big husky.
eh October 11, 2012 at 06:42 PM
Attributing this to the pond without having anyone actually investigate the report indicates a few steps were missed. If this can also be found in puddles, then the connection is quite a big leap


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something