patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Address Mix-up Delays Ambulance For Heart Attack Victim in Wainscott

Lanny Ross' widow wants to ensure similar addresses never cause another dispatching mistake during an emergency.

 

When Lanny Ross showed the symptoms of a heart attack on Sunday night, his wife, now his widow, called 911, but ambulance personnel who quickly got on the road to bring him help were delayed by what Sherri Ross is calling "one huge mistake."

East Hampton Village dispatchers received the call at 8:14 p.m., according to police records. Ross said she told the dispatcher she thought her husband was having a heart attack and gave him her exact location: 419 Montauk Highway in Wainscott. However, dispatchers toned out the call to the ambulance company from the neighboring fire district and sent them to 419 Montauk Highway in East Hampton instead.

Lanny Ross, 51, was pronounced dead at Southampton Hospital at around 9:30 p.m., his widow said.

Kenneth Collum, director of the East Hampton Village Communications Department, confirmed on Friday that Ross gave her exact location, including the hamlet.

"There are four 419 Montauk Highways in East Hampton Town—in East Hampton, Wainscott, Montauk and Amagansett," noted Collum. He explained that the dispatcher punched the address into a computer software program and a drop-down then appeared on his screen to select the correct fire district boundary for the address. The dispatcher simply checked the wrong one, Collum said.

"Obviously, it's unacceptable," he went on to say. "It's something we're looking at … to make this a better procedure to ensure this doesn't happen again." He added, "Everyone knew Lanny," a former chief in the Amagansett Fire Department. "It strikes a different cord with everybody here."

In recalling that night, Ross said, "I told them exactly where we were, and while I was calling 911, I ran downstairs and turned all the lights on so they could find us." She then ran back to her husband's side.

"They asked me if my husband was breathing," she said. "I thought that he was because he was making a grunting sound. They asked me if I could get him on the floor. I asked them when are the ambulance personnel going to be here to help me."

The dispatcher walked her through rescue breathing and chest compressions, she said, but she kept asking about help. "They seemed to be having trouble finding the house. The dispatcher said to turn on an outside light, to send someone down to the driveway. I sent my 16-year-old daughter down. She went out into the street."

"They said, 'There's nothing there'," Ross said. "But I was saying 'I'm here!'"

In fact, nothing exists at 419 Montauk Highway in East Hampton, which should be in the area of  East Hampton Urgent Care. The distance between 418 Montauk Highway in East Hampton, an address that does exist, and the Ross house in Wainscott is 5.45 miles, about a 12-minute drive in regular traffic.

While Ross said she couldn't gauge how long it actually took ambulance crews to arrive at her house, she said it felt like an eternity. East Hampton Patch has filed a Freedom of Information request with East Hampton Village for a time log of the call.

Collum said the East Hampton ambulance was rerouted shortly after it left the ambulance barn. He said it was the dispatchers who realized the mistake, not those who arrived at the wrong location.

Town officers were also sent to the wrong address. They were the first to arrive at the correct address, followed by East Hampton Village Ambulance Association vehicles, according to Ross. She said she was thankful for the police and ambulance personnel who were "professional, courteous and calming in the middle of this traumatic moment."

Collum explained that two East Hampton ambulances arrived at the scene, the one that signed on after the initial call and another that happened to be on its way back from Southampton Hospital. When the mistake was realized, dispatchers toned out the call to the Bridgehampton Fire Department Ambulance Company, which should have received the call in the first place.  

In total, four advanced emergency medical technicians and one paramedic came to the call, Collum said. Bridgehampton transported the patient to the hospital.

Having just buried her husband on Thursday, Ross is left with questions. "If that call were handled differently, would my husband be alive? If Bridgehampton had been dispatched right away and the police had been dispatched right away, would it have made a difference? We'll never know," she said.

 "We are thoroughly reviewing the details of the call, dispatcher responses, and the computer aids used in this call," East Hampton Village Administrator Larry Cantwell said Friday. "Any changes that need to be made will be implemented forthwith."

According to Collum, one of the problems was that Ross' phone number did not give her location. "It was a 604 number. I'm not sure if it's Vonage or iO. Vonage is a problem for the 911 community because the number can be from anywhere."

Ross, who said she reached out to Cantwell on Friday to ensure the problem would be addressed, said improving the 911 system is what's most important to her. "Just asking the question, 'What happened?,' can save somebody else's life." She said, "Nobody should have to go through what we went through."

Amy Tangel

9:11 pm on Friday, November 19, 2010

What a heart wrenching story. My sympathies to the Ross family. Great job Taylor. Hopefully this story will encourage changes that will prevent this mistake from happening again.

Reply

Karen Hochstedler

8:55 am on Saturday, November 20, 2010

This is so sad. My heart goes out to Mrs. Ross and her family.

Reply

Donald Kuss

9:29 am on Saturday, November 20, 2010

Great job Taylor, somebody has to set things straight and get the truth.

Reply

Jonathan Lerner

9:34 am on Saturday, November 20, 2010

A very sad story to read, words can not express your loss Mrs. Ross lets hope we can learn from the error and improve upon the system so this never happens again...

Reply

PJ Delia

1:13 pm on Saturday, November 20, 2010

Sad. My hearts and prayers go out to the family.
I appreciate the detailed coverage. I imagine most readers had no idea Vonage or IO would not automatically show an address to 911 dispatchers.

Reply
Patch_comments_icon

Taylor K. Vecsey

1:29 pm on Saturday, November 20, 2010

Editor's note: We are waiting a detailed report to understand exactly why the address did not come up.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Sally

12:34 am on Tuesday, November 23, 2010

I have the same problem. I live on Merchants Path in Wainscott. Everybody thinks its the Merchants Path in Sagaponack. Plus 6 years ago the houses were renumbered. GPS don't know where I live. Some people put in Sag Harbor, others EAst Hampton. Utilities, emergency services, nobody can find me. When I went to the town to discuss, for this purpose exactly, nobody could tell me they could help me. It's ridiculous. Please help!!

PJ Delia

2:45 pm on Saturday, November 20, 2010

Good to know. Thank you, Taylor.

Reply

Mark Ballou

8:33 am on Friday, December 3, 2010

This highlights the problem of saving money with Vonage or iO or any computer VOIP system, there is no connection to your address. Had they been using a land line phone, the 911 call would have known immediately EXACTLY what the address was. ALSO, in dialing 911, TELL them your cross streets, so they know how to get to you quickly. I lived in a rural area where the street I lived on started and stopped five times (with no access between them), the only way to get to my home was to know what street to turn on that would access my section of the street.

Reply

Leave a comment